Archive for the ‘Earth 2’ Category

EARTH-2-9-CoverWritten by: James Robinson
Art by: Nicola Scott, Trevor Scott
Cover by: Nicola Scott, Trevor Scott
Variant Cover by: Nicola Scott, Trevor Scott

It’s incredibly difficult to move a story at a snail’s pace and keep it interesting.  This is one of James Robinson’s trademarks, and it’s never done him well.  Yet something has brightened up his writing skills as every single issue of Earth 2 so far has been absolutely fantastic.  Of course, the biggest question that’s plaguing every reader’s mind is…will this clump of “wonders” ever become a team, forming the inevitable Justice Society?

After the polite shunning Green Lantern bestowed upon the other “lesser” super-powered mortals, a vanishing occurred, as so it says on page one.  Hawkgirl and Flash are remaining teammates, yet have gone their own separate ways for a brief period on some personal errands.  While Flash is making certain his mother is ok, Hawkgirl makes a plea to Khalid-Ben-Hassin to place the Helm of Fate on his head and take up arms with her and Flash.  Reluctant as he is, he decides to help, but as a man, not a hero.  In the meantime, Jay Garrick has a run-in with the Atom and company while checking in with his mother, and right before the final blow by soldiers of the World Army, magical forces make a last minute rescue.  But the trifecta of Hawgirl, Flash, and the yet-to-be-crowned Dr. Fate seem to be in even more trouble than before they left the land of the known.

I enjoy a good “plotty” story from time to time, and this is certainly a goodie.  The pacing is great, moving fast enough to keep the action interesting, yet holding back an appropriate amount of story-progressing material that’s all coming out in this issue, mostly dealing with the introduction of new characters both good and bad.  Dr. Fate making his come back was a giddy moment for me, as odd as it seemed.  In fact, with every aspect of this run comes a strange sense of oddity.  Being 31 years old, having read comics as much as I have since 1992, my memories of the Society are as an older, more stylistic team up that maintained a very different and vintage montage and persona.  With that being said, it’s very weird to see all of these characters I’m more familiar with as elderly folks drawn as younger egocentric personalities.  It’s a new perspective on a set of heroes we are all to familiar with before the New 52 started.  It’s one of the few titles that served it’s purpose exceptionally well since the reboot.

It’s a very good story that makes you wonder what the heck’s going to happen in 3o days, and how the Hell you’ll survive until then.  Don’t ponder on it too much because you can always go back to Nicola Scott’s perfect artistry, bringing each character to life in ways most artists can only dream of.  Page one, as simple as it was, was amazing with Hawkgirl’s wing spread, as well as the massive detail work done on Khalid’s office home.  Could I draw like Scott does?  I’m sure I could…but no way am I going to try to do this as consistently and regularly as she does.  Wow!

It’s a great issue that proves DC’s doing all they can to make sure their stories are top-notch.  There’s been some misses amongst DC’s regime of titles, but Earth 2 isn’t one of them.

9 out of 10 stars

Earth 2 #6 Review

Posted: November 8, 2012 in Comic Book Review, DC Comics, Earth 2
Written by: James Robinson
Pencilled by: Nicola Scott
Inked by: Trevor Scott
Cover by: Ivan Reis, Joe Prado
Variant Cover by: Ivan Reis
Color/B&W: Color
Page Count: 32
U.S. Price: 2.99

The changes in costumes, sexual orientation, and origins isn’t what gives this revamping of the DCU’s Golden Age of superheroes a fresh jolt in the new 52.  James Robinson has simply found his hitch – a literary venue where he can expand on his strengths and wright stories that have a balanced mix of action and meaningful storytelling.  Giving life to the golden age of superheroes in a different dimension from Earth prime (I’m assuming) allows us, the readers, to make more sense of having more than one Flash, Green Lantern, etc etc etc.  Robinson’s been given the opportunity to give these heroes a new start and purpose that’s grand and fun to read.

And abundance of exposition is Robinson’s signature writing technique, which has probably been his downfall in past story arcs.  Starting with issue #1 to now of Earth 2 has been filled with dialog balloons that detail every inch of the plot, minimizing how much work Nicola Scott’s has to do on the artistic front.  There seems to be a lot of great teamwork between Scott and Robinson however as nothing on both the literary and artistic sides of the book are too overbearing or made to compensate for a lack of quality on either side.

The Amazing Nicola Scott Ladies And Gentlemen!

Everything in the book seems to be working quite well – the bickering “relationship” that Flash and Hawkgirl are developing, Atom’s obligation and determination to follow orders, Green Lantern’s other worldly mindset that’s progressively infusing him with this holier-than-thou personality, and Sloan’s mysterious and seemingly devious ulterior motives all give this issue a fantastic catapult into future conflicts and character developing plot lines.

Nicola Scott, as amazing as always, brings an amazing amount of life to this title.  Though I’m not quite certain I understand the reasoning for the ghostly appearance of the cover, unless it’s loosely connected to Alan Scott and his boyfriend Sam’s afterlife moment, but the story itself bears virtually no relationship with Blackest Night.  No points against what’s inside of course since every panel on every page is filled with emotion and color.

Much like what we find in the movies, the resolve delivers a classic superhero ending to the first arc of Earth 2.  It may be a be cliche, but it’s suits this title just right.  I’m uncertain of the longevity of Earth 2, but if it ends after one year to give birth to a Justice Society title, I’ll be on board!

9 out of 10 stars

Earth 2 #0 Review

Posted: September 6, 2012 in Comic Book Review, DC Comics, Earth 2
Written by: James Robinson
Cover by: Ivan ReisJoe Prado
Variant Cover by: Ivan Reis

Betrayal and the birth of Earth 2′s deadliest enemy is at the heart of this issue.  Terry Sloane, the original Mr. Terrific, (before the reboot) is costumed in such a way unfamiliar to veteran readers, and all that remains recognizable is the name.  Terry is a the smartest man on Earth, (whether this is self proclaimed or factual has been left undetermined) and he’s figured out the ultimate solution to the zombified citizens problem…blow up the major continents of the world!

Are you surprised though?  How many action stories end with a resolution culminated in the form of a mushroom cloud, TNT, and some form of explosion?  The answer shouldn’t surprise you, and Earth 2 #0 is no exception.  The last page shows a familiar splash of Earth resembling a dark and gruesome planet from another dimension.  Despite this issue’s typical format, it’s still loads of fun and a great read.  Nothing truly surprising comes out of it however.  Rather, it’s more of a precursor to an inevitable event with Terry Sloane leading the villainous charge.

Robinson gives us a nice sneak peak into the character of Sloane – he’s intelligent and witty, yet rude enough to be interesting.  He was smart in not including the Ternion (Batman, Superman, Wonder Woman) of Earth 2 in on his plan…they never agree to it.  But being the smartest man on Earth comes with its biases, and Terry’s of the mindset that the quick resolution will benefit the world more than the prolonged.  It makes one wonder just how SMART he actually is.  No doubt this will be an intense fight, and seeing as how the Ternion survived the explosion, Earth 2 is going to have a major onslaught of supers coming in – fists blaring and feet kicking.

I was very impressed with the art; exploding cities, the destruction of classically famous monuments, burning bodies until nothing but the skeleton is visible, all created in a fiery fusion of reds and yellows.  Not being to familiar with Giorello’s art, this was a delightfully new visual experience for me.  He also does wonders with the up-skirt shot of Wonder Woman’s nether regions…

Was this purposeful? You decide.

Giorello does a fantastic job at fusing canvas style painting and comic book style penciling, making everything look much more prestigious than your typical comic book does.  With every page turn the action gets more and more explosive, and equally as beautiful.  I certainly hope Giorello sticks around on this book for a year.

Earth 2 is slowly becoming one of my favorite books from DC’s line.  I’m looking forward to the story and how this is going to tie into the yet-to-be-named Justice Society!

10 out of 10 stars

Written by: James Robinson
Cover by: Ivan Reis
Variant Cover by: Ivan Reis

The reboot has been good for Mr. Robinson - erasing his past writing contributions and starting fresh with better stories.  It’s clear James Robinson has carefully planned everything out.  It’s also been clear that the writer has always been excellent at action stories, but dialog has never been his forte.  And while the dialog could still use a Midas Touch, the story is as good as anything DC has put out within the last year.

With this issue comes the reintroduction of an old character, one that fans will be drooling over. Captain Pratt is much more than he was prior to the reboot and will take [seasoned] fans by surprise.  I’m not incredibly knowledgeable of Atom’s past or origins, but I think it’s safe to say this resembles very little of pre-New 52, but might be 100% better.

With Atom filling in the book’s beginning and end, the middle stars Jay Garrick, who’s dumbfounded by the obvious choice in alias, and Hawkgirl, who’s just as feisty and argumentative as she was before before the hooded lady “fixed” the DC continuity.  There was a nice little humorous moment where we learn of Jay Garrick’s future as the team leader, which made me smile…

The Justice Society is slowly getting closer to being formed, paced well without getting too weighed down in boring plot progressions.  I have a feeling the team will come together in one glorious final battle against one mighty enemy…could it be Grundy or something much more fierce?

Speaking of which, I’m rather enjoying the two Earth’s different versions of the Rot and the Green AND their avatars.  (However, if Alan Scott is still weakened by wood, I’m not sure I’ll buy it.)  It also gives Alan Scott a much better place within this world’s (Earth 2) repertoire of superheroes, as well as some of the heroes all having the same name.  (example…the Flash.)  I always felt it confusing to have A Green Lantern Corps with its officers subject to the rule of the Guardians…and then there’s Alan Scott who had nothing to do with them.  Sticking Scott on Earth 2 sits a lot better with me.

The team has a lot to contribute to the (yet to be formed) society, with each member bringing in their own unique talents.  Like Wonder Woman, Hawkgirl seems to be the balancing point between the irrational and big headed.  And while Jay will bring in inexperience, his constant need to know the facts will mirror the Dark Knight Detective in so many ways.  Alan Scott will, of course, act out the Superman role, and Atom has so much Guy Gardner in him, it’s almost overwhelming.

Nicola Scott always proves to be one of the best artists in the biz, and Trevor Scott takes charge of the inks in a gorgeous array of lines.

Earth 2 is slowly becoming one of my favorite titles and I’m glad to see the Society coming back to the DCU.  More to come in 30.

10 out of 10 stars

Written by: James Robinson
Cover by: Ivan ReisJoe Prado
Variant Cover by: Ivan ReisJoe Prado

So let’s go ahead and get it out there, this issue will do well in the sales department with the latest “coming out” moment delivering DC’s first gay superhero.  But there’s more meat to this issue than a mere hot button topic that’s receiving both scrutiny and praise.  Jay Garrick finds himself in a speedy pickle, shockingly receiving the power of the Roman God, Mercury.

While jay is figuring out his new powers, Mr. Terrific of Earth1 has traveled through a worm hole to Earth 2 where he meets a man who, somehow, was expecting him.

If you’re looking to hear my thoughts on Alan Scott’s recent change in sexual orientation, you’re not going to hear anything mind blowing.  The whole development is arguably dull.  However, at issue’s end, delivery of a cliffhanger should promise great story building potential.  But I think the most appropriate reaction to the news was from Mr. Jimmy Fallon – click link below…

Pros and Cons: The Gay Green Lantern (6/5/12).

But to be honest, what we see between Alan and Sam isn’t unique in and of itself, and any other display of love and affection in comics like this would be just as cheesy and frightfully irrelevant…until next month of course.

It’s not all that difficult to make connections when titles cross over into other title’s continuity.  However, it still irks me to pick up a book and discover that I needed to read a different title in order to make sense of things.  Is DC really going to compel me to read Mr. Terrific simply because they tied it in with Earth 2?  Despite the fact that I don’t actually NEED to read Mr. Terrific to understand what happened, it’s still a little vexing.

But with the teleportation of the world’s 3rd smartest man, we are placed in this world that still morns the death of the trinity of wonders which has affected everyday life on Earth 2.  No doubt this title’s first arc or two will be all about raising the spirits of its inhabitants and bringing peace and happiness back to the world, with no mindless “nut jobs” roaming the streets, spouting out random jargon that seemingly has no place in this issue.

Robinson has done good! And that’s certainly saying something if any of you know my disdain for the writer.  This is certainly turning out to be a great book…knock on wood.

Oh crap, I may have just jinxed Alan Scott!

9 out of 10 stars

Writer: James Robinson
Penciller: Nicola Scott
Inker: Trevor Scott
Colorist: Alex Sinclair
Letterer: Dezi Sienty
Cover by: Ivan Reis, Rod Reis, & Joe Prado

War is upon us!  Or at least on some alternate version of US over on Earth two.  The DC trinity isn’t the evil band of antiheroes fans were fearing them to be, but rather a trifecta of goodness and crime fighting.  What’s the difference then?  They’re a little more ready to slice and dice than Earth One’s trinity.

Despite their best efforts, the three head honchos of Earth two were unable to sustain their lives in battle, but not before thwarting the invasion plans (or at least delaying them a bit) of Darkseid and his henchmen.  Another worry has been laid to rest!  This title will NOT be dominated by the big three, but rather by a team of old superheroes, seemingly discovering the fountain of youth…or a Lazarus pit.  Alan Scott and Jay Garrick return at the book’s end, but with far less silver hairs.

Alan begins his time on this book by simply commemorating the memory of American soldiers, while looking down in terrifying awe of the fiery pits below his plane.  Jay Garrick endures the most, however, when his girlfriend basically rips off his manhood by way of calling him worthless, and leaves him to pursue more “realistic” and “hopeful” aspirations.  Of course, Jay gets winded by a Greek God, which will spurn Garrick’s speedy abilities by next month I’m sure.
——————————————————————————-

I’ll be honest with you, I was leaning more on the side of “HELL NO” when deciding if I wanted to pick this title up; me and James Robinson don’t mix!  Did you guys read World of New Krypton?  If you did, you’ll know why I was hesitant.  However, I figured, why not?  I can always give it a bad review and never pick up another issue right?

Turns out James Robinson isn’t as bad as I thought he was.  Don’t tell you mom and dad though, the upcoming Justice Society is younger than Superman and friends – they just might tip over and die.

But that’s not where the focus lies, it’s just a nice little twist to a stellar comic.  It’s the big three that are at center stage.  This version of Supes and Wondy might be better than the ones I’m familiar with.  Although, Wonder Woman does seem hell bent on killing everything.  I think she might say “Kill as many as I can” five times in this issue…

Destroy All Humans…

Earth 2′s Superman and Wonder Woman seem to have switched roles, Superman being the philosopher and Wonder Woman acted out the “leap-before-you-look” role.  I still like them, it just made to do a double take.

Batman isn’t worth the time he’s put on the pages.  He sure packs a wallop before meeting his demise though, and that’s worth the cover price!

The only thing I’m a little “iffy” about is the “young” JSA.  The team hasn’t formed yet, with only a brief look at two of its most prominent (or will be) heroes.  The Society has always been a league that has commanded respect with its elderly chaps, and now they are young and inexperienced – not something I wanted to see happen in the new 52.

However, there is an appealing aspect of only having ONE Flash per dimension; Earth One has Barry, Earth Two has Jay.  I hope it stays this way for a while, I don’t need so many different versions of the same hero skipping around on the same earthly plane.

Nicola Scott always gives me the best artistic boner, (yes, I just went there) never wavering on the detail, but not going to far.  The opening page where the parademons swoop down towards land from the sky is breathtaking…makes me wish it was stretched out into a splash page!

James Robinson makes the upset, delivering a comic book completely worth the $3.99 price mark.  I promise you all, if you haven’t picked this up, do so…You’ll be happy you did!

9 out of 10 stars